Consider:

What should I use as a base for my wall mounted PC case?

Looking at the 'Note, the following are considered off-topic:' section, it is a Hobby project. But as per this section: 'We welcome these topics:' it does seem to fit in on this site:

  1. Questions you would typically ask a home contractor. [No, well maybe]
  2. Which tools and materials to use for a specific task. [Yes]
  3. Best practices for a specific task. [Yes]
  4. Identifying the source or cause of a problem within your home. [No]
  5. National building codes (of any country). [Nope]
  6. Installation, maintenance, and repair of major appliances. [No]
  7. Carpentry and woodworking. [Yes]

I feel there is a need for a site dedicated to all other DIY projects that include hobby projects too.

See here: DIY-projects

share
2  
Number 2 should probably be "Which tools and materials to use for a specific home improvement task", as well as number 3 "Best practices for a specific home Improvement task". So in your case, only number 7 would apply, and only if you chose to use wood. –  Tester101 Dec 21 '12 at 14:11
    
+1 Yup.. Similarly #3 should be more specific too. –  Kent Pawar Dec 21 '12 at 14:17
    
@Tester101 could you suggest other projects besides Home-Improvement and hobby projects that would be a part of DIY-projects. Of course hobby projects would benefit from the knowledge generated on this site but would cover a broader area of construction materials.. –  Kent Pawar Dec 21 '12 at 14:18
add comment

1 Answer

Currently, there isn't a site to migrate it to, so an area51 proposal is the best option. There was an attempt in the past to have a personal manufacturing site, but that failed. You may want to consider how much of the maker community you can include with your proposal since they would be helpful in getting your site off the ground.

As for why it's off topic here, getting into hobby projects gets out of the expertise of this community and can quickly become a very broad and ambiguous subject. Personally, I tend to watch Mike Holmes and This Old House, but I don't participate in the local hacker space, these are two distinct communities to me. In the past, there have been attempts to create sites around personal electronics that failed because they became very broad with too few people that could answer the questions. The lesson there is that we don't want a site that's so broad that anyone can ask a question, but no one is around to answer it. The model adopted by SE is sites that have a well defined scope that can attract a core group able the answer the questions. Unfortunately, this means that good questions don't always have a place where they can be asked.

share
    
Good points @BMitch!Thanks –  Kent Pawar Dec 22 '12 at 8:57
1  
Although Personal Manufacturing failed,we did start a new proposal to reboot it –  Mark Booth Dec 22 '12 at 19:53
add comment

You must log in to answer this question.

Not the answer you're looking for? Browse other questions tagged .